Auctions

Mack C. Chase Walking Liberty Halves Return in Stack's Bowers November Sale

300+ Chase Collection Walking Liberty halves sell Nov. 16–25 after Part I's $2.45M. View the lots in Baltimore Nov. 10–13 during the Whitman Expo.

Written by Admin User

Sculptor Adolph A. Weinman, designer of the Walking Liberty half dollar, in his studio about 1915 with a draped model and a round relief on an easel
Image: Smithsonian Institution, Archives of American Art · Public domain · commons.wikimedia.org

More than 300 Walking Liberty half dollars from the Mack C. Chase Collection are headed back to the auction block in November. It is the second offering from a cabinet whose first part brought nearly $2.5 million in September. Stack's Bowers Galleries will sell the coins in its November 2026 Showcase Auction, and East Coast collectors can see them in person during the Whitman Baltimore Expo before the sale.

What's in Part II

Stack's Bowers announced the sale on October 6. CoinWeek ran a detailed preview on October 26. The Walking Liberty halves fill a special session, which CoinWeek lists as Session 4, lots 4001 through 4303. The early dates are the draw. The firm's highlight list:

  • 1916: MS-67 PCGS, CAC. CoinWeek notes it also carries a CMQ (Collectible Market Qualified) designation.
  • 1916-S: MS-66 PCGS, in an old green-label holder
  • 1918-D and 1918-S: both MS-66 NGC
  • 1919, 1919-D, 1919-S: MS-66, MS-65 and MS-66 PCGS, all CAC
  • 1920-D and 1920-S: MS-65 and MS-66 PCGS, both CAC
  • 1921, 1921-D, 1921-S: MS-65 PCGS CAC, MS-66 NGC, and MS-65 PCGS CAC
Obverse of a 1945-D Walking Liberty half dollar
Weinman's Liberty striding toward the sun (1945-D shown, not a Chase coin). Photo: Brandon Grossardt, Wikimedia Commons, public domain
Reverse of a 1945-D Walking Liberty half dollar
The eagle reverse, 1945-D. Photo: Brandon Grossardt, Wikimedia Commons, public domain

The 1916 is a first-year Philadelphia coin from a mintage of 608,000. CoinWeek reports that PCGS has graded only one 1916 higher than MS-67, a single MS-67+. Stack's Bowers president Brian Kendrella called the Chase holdings a "world class cabinet." He said many of the halves have been off the market for decades, so "today's collectors are getting their first opportunity to bid" on them.

The Walking Liberty halves are not the whole offering. The main catalog adds pieces from Chase's other interests: small cents, Buffalo nickels, Mercury dimes, type coins, gold, patterns, and an 1879 Flowing Hair $4 Stella.

1879 Flowing Hair $4 Stella pattern, obverse and reverse
An 1879 Flowing Hair Stella in the Smithsonian's collection, not the Chase example. Photo: Jaclyn Nash, National Numismatic Collection, public domain

September set the bar

The first Chase offering sold on September 3, 2026, alongside Stack's Bowers' Summer Global Showcase, an Event Auctioneer Partner of the ANA World's Fair of Money. According to the firm's results release, 253 lots brought $2,448,125 with buyer's premiums, and several coins set auction records.

LotCoinGradePrice
40501921-DPCGS MS-66 CAC CMQ$183,000 (record)
—1917-D, reverse mintmarkPCGS MS-67$122,000 (record)
40291918-DPCGS MS-66$115,900
40311918-SPCGS MS-66 CAC CMQ$91,500 (date record)
40451920-SNGC MS-67$85,400 (NGC record)
40041916-DPCGS MS-67 CAC CMQ$56,120 (record)
41431940NGC MS-69$39,040 (date record)

CoinWeek adds that a 1921-S in PCGS MS-65 brought $109,800. Stack's Bowers called the 1940 the only Walking Liberty half in that grade for the series. After the sale, John M. Pack, the firm's executive director of consignments, said the next part would come in November.

The design and its condition rarities

Adolph A. Weinman won the 1916 design competition. The Mint struck the first coins late that year and released them in January 1917. The series ran through 1947, and Weinman's Liberty came back in 1986 on the obverse of the American Silver Eagle. Wikipedia's history of the series says no date is especially rare overall, but many dates are scarce in Mint State, particularly the 1921 and 1921-D. It also notes that the design was hard to strike fully, and San Francisco coins in particular often came out weak. Strike is worth checking on any S-mint Walker, including the Chase 1916-S, 1919-S, and 1920-S, if you view the lots in person.

Reverse of a 1921 Walking Liberty half dollar in a museum display
A 1921 half dollar, reverse, on display at the Bode-Museum in Berlin. Photo: Daderot, Wikimedia Commons, public domain

The collector behind the coins

CoinWeek's profile describes how Chase came to the series. He was born in Texas and raised in southeastern New Mexico near the Permian Basin. He went to work in the oil fields in 1945, at age 14. When he started working, the Walking Liberty half was the largest denomination the Mint still made for circulation. Apart from two years in the Army, he stayed in that community, and his business grew into oil and gas, ranching, livestock, land management, and pecan farming. CoinWeek says he collected quietly and went after quality, tough dates, and eye appeal.

How to view and bid

Stack's Bowers' auction calendar gives these details for the November Showcase:

  • Sale dates: November 16–20 and November 23–25, at Griffin Studios in Costa Mesa, California. CoinWeek's listing dates the Chase session to November 18.
  • Online viewing: on StacksBowers.com through November 20
  • In-person viewing: New York, November 4–6, by appointment. Baltimore Convention Center, Room 307, November 10–13.
  • Status: Stack's Bowers bills the sale as the official auction of the Whitman Expos.

See the lots at the Baltimore show

Lot viewing in Baltimore overlaps with the Whitman Coin & Collectibles Expo – Baltimore Fall. The show runs November 12–14 in Halls A–C of the Baltimore Convention Center, One West Pratt Street. Admission is free. A dealer-only PNG Dealer Day comes first, on November 11. You can see the Chase coins in hand and then work the bourse for Walkers in your own budget. For other events in the state, see Maryland coin shows. West Coast collectors near the auction's home base can check California coin shows.

Share: