Auctions

Five-Known 1885 Trade Dollar Goes on View in Baltimore Before Stack's Bowers Sale

A PCGS Proof-63+ 1885 Trade dollar, one of five known, can be seen in Baltimore Nov. 10-13 before it sells in Stack's Bowers' Rarities Night on Nov. 17.

Written by Admin User

Obverse and reverse of an 1873 Trade dollar, shown as a stand-in for the 1885 issue
Image: National Numismatic Collection, National Museum of American History · Public domain · commons.wikimedia.org

One of only five known 1885 Trade dollars will be available for in-person viewing in Baltimore next week. The coin, graded PCGS Proof-63+ with CAC approval, is part of a group CoinWeek describes as Property from an Alabama Family. It sells November 17 in Stack's Bowers Galleries' Rarities Night session, and the preview overlaps with the free Whitman Baltimore Expo.

An 1873 Trade dollar, obverse and reverse
An 1873 Trade dollar, shown for the design; this is not the 1885 coin. National Numismatic Collection, photo by Jaclyn Nash, public domain

What's on view in Room 307

According to CoinWeek's November 4 show preview, lot viewing runs from Tuesday, November 10, through Friday, November 13, from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. in Room 307 of the Baltimore Convention Center. Viewing ends a day before the show does, so plan on Saturday for the bourse only.

CoinWeek lists these highlights from the Alabama property:

  • 1885 Trade dollar: PCGS Proof-63+, CAC approved
  • 1794 Flowing Hair dollar: NGC MS-62+, with a pedigree to the Larry H. Miller Collection
  • 1792 half disme: NGC MS-65
  • 1879 Flowing Hair Stella: Proof-66 Deep Cameo (the preview doesn't name the grading service)
  • 1851 Augustus Humbert $50 gold piece: no grade given in the preview

The preview gives no estimates for these coins, and we won't guess at them. The Baltimore room is for viewing only. CoinWeek reports that the sale has 11 live and online sessions on November 16–20 and November 23–25, with the live sessions at the firm's Griffin Studios in Costa Mesa, California.

A 1794 Flowing Hair dollar
A 1794 dollar, not the Alabama coin. Smithsonian Institution image, public domain
An 1879 Flowing Hair Stella, obverse and reverse
An 1879 Flowing Hair Stella, not the Alabama coin. National Numismatic Collection, photo by Jaclyn Nash, public domain
A 1792 half disme in a grading holder, obverse
A 1792 half disme, not the Alabama coin. Photo: Wehwalt, Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Why the 1885 Trade dollar is so unusual

The Trade dollar began in 1873 as a silver coin meant to compete with Mexican pesos in Asian commerce. It measured 38.1 mm, weighed 27.22 grams, and was 90 percent silver. The U.S. demonetized it in 1876, and circulation strikes ended in 1878, while Philadelphia kept making proofs for collectors.

Then the record goes quiet. Just Collecting News reported in 2019 that the Mint has no record of producing the 1885 issue. TradeDollar.org says the 1884 and 1885 coins surfaced more than two decades later and caused a sensation, despite their doubtful origins.

Explanations differ, and none is settled:

  • A secret striking: a Philadelphia Mint employee made them without authorization
  • A cancelled proof set: they were legitimate coins meant for a set that never went ahead
  • The superintendent's coins: COINage raises the possibility that they were struck by or for Archibald Louden Snowden, who left his post as Philadelphia Mint superintendent in mid-1885

Just Collecting also reported in 2019 that the Smithsonian, the American Numismatic Society, and the American Numismatic Association didn't own an example, so you couldn't count on seeing one in those collections. CoinWeek's 2020 coverage placed the issue at No. 15 in the 2019 edition of Garrett and Guth's 100 Greatest U.S. Coins.

How the other examples have fared

Sources we read document three notable market appearances by 1885 examples. Grades are as reported at the time.

SpecimenGradeReported event
EliasbergNGC PF 66$3,960,000, Heritage at FUN, Jan. 10, 2019
SimpsonPCGS PR63+CAM$2.1 million hammer, Heritage, Jan. 20, 2021
E. Horatio MorganPCGS Proof-64Announced for Stack's Bowers' Baltimore sale, March 2020

The Eliasberg coin is the finest known. Just Collecting reported that Utah collector Dell Loy Hansen bought it in 2019, and that it had last traded privately for $3.3 million in January 2006. CoinWeek's 2020 article lists it as PCGS Proof-65+ Cameo, which differs from the NGC grade it carried when it sold.

The Morgan coin's earlier appearances include the Fred Olsen sale of 1944, the George Ewalt sale of 1965, and the L.R. French sale of 1989. We couldn't confirm the outcome of the 2020 offering, so we've left it out.

One open question: the Alabama coin's grade is close to the Simpson coin's. COINage lists Simpson's past owners as including Waldo Newcomer, E.H.R. Green, Jerome Kern, and Amon Carter. But CoinWeek's preview gives no pedigree for the Alabama coin, and none of the sources we read says the two are the same. The Stack's Bowers catalog is the place to check.

Planning your Baltimore visit

The Whitman Coin & Collectibles Expo – Baltimore Fall runs November 12–14 in Halls A, B, and C of the Baltimore Convention Center, 1 West Pratt Street. Whitman confirms the show is free and open to the public. CoinWeek reports these details:

  • Public hours: Thursday noon–6 p.m., Friday 10 a.m.–6 p.m., Saturday 10 a.m.–4 p.m.
  • Early-bird entry: $100, starting at 10 a.m. Thursday and 9 a.m. Friday and Saturday
  • ID: government-issued photo ID required for visitors 16 and older
  • Entrance: the Charles Street Lobby
  • Grading: PCGS won't grade on-site but accepts submissions at its offices; NGC and PMG also accept regular submissions
Baltimore Convention Center seen across a paved plaza
The Baltimore Convention Center, seen from a skywalk in 2004. Photo: KSweeley, Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Trade-only PNG Dealer Day comes first, on Wednesday, November 11. Early American collectors may also want to catch Robert L. Rodriguez signing The Continental Dollar: A Journey of Discovery on Thursday at 1:30 p.m.

The same preview room also holds the second part of the Mack C. Chase Collection, which has its own session on November 18. We covered that sale in our earlier report on the Chase Walking Liberty halves.

Where to see it

Your stop for the Alabama coins is the Whitman Baltimore Expo, with the viewing room open through Friday afternoon. For another Maryland show later in the month, the Cambridge Coin Show is listed for November 21, and our Maryland coin shows page has more events in the state.

Share: